As you can tell, the cemetery was pretty wooded, and I have to admit I was not wearing the right clothes or shoes to be walking. I didn't get the best shots, but what are you going to do? This cemetery is now the eternal resting place of the 64 original settlers of Finneytown, a neighboring city, which included several Revolutionary War veterans as well as the founder of Finneytown. According to this article, the first burial took place in 1799 and the last one taking place in 1891. While it appears mostly abandoned, newer headstones for the veterans replace the older, rundown ones.
The cemetery itself isn't super spooky, but as soon as we got out of the car Haley told me a girl was murdered and her body was found at the reservoir next to the cemetery. I can deal with ghosts, but the thought of someone being snatched and murdered by a random person scares the bejesus out of me. Fortunately, the girls killer was found but it only happened in 2009 which hits close to home because I was living in Cincinnati at that time. Despite the dismal history, the cemetery is worth the visit!
How to get to the cemetery
The cemetery sits on Winton Ridge Lane to the immediate south of the Winton Water Reservoir. You'll drive past the building and it's right next to the driveway. You will probably miss it if you aren't looking for it.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0d2c4/0d2c4e416a540110edadc6d6f2033ae6d9308885" alt=""